11 Comments
User's avatar
Amy Colleen's avatar

I like the principle of this piece, or at least I did at first, but you lost me at "I use AI to write captions." What about *that* rural village?

Adam Cayton-Holland's avatar

very much get that. Think I'm moving on from that to typing them out. They get half the shit wrong anyway. But you're right!

Amy Colleen's avatar

I want to apologize to you because I misinterpreted initially! Your follow-up made me realize you were talking about *closed* captioning and not generating "original" text to write a caption for a photo in a post! One is transcription and the other is generative so yes, I agree there is a difference. I still applaud the desire to move away from it in general but I am sorry I misunderstood at first!

Adam Cayton-Holland's avatar

oh yeah. I would never. I'll write my own captions for photos thanks! But yeah, like I said, I'm not as pure as the driven snow, I just want people to examine their relationship with it all. I could see great medical, environmental, safety uses for AI, but none of that seems to be happening. Or at least not capturing the attention. In art, I find it poisonous. Anyway, thanks for the interest/discourse!

Patrick Pratt's avatar

Awesome essay! Thanks! But Cincinnati, Cleveland and Pittsburgh, but no Columbus?

Adam Cayton-Holland's avatar

It's a bummer for sure! Sorry bruh.

Ryan's avatar

I saw your poster at Sun Market and loved it! Congrats on the Skylark show, we were bummed we couldn’t make it. I grew up in cleveland and shared the Topps poster with my friends there encouraging them to go. May your visit to cleveland this winter be as joyful as Jameis Winston’s :) https://www.tiktok.com/@nflonprime/video/7447262003070029098

Adam Cayton-Holland's avatar

hey thanks, Ryan! Appreciate the Cleveland assist! I will be as grateful as Jameis Winston every step of the way, and eat all the snow I see!

Joanna Kimbrell's avatar

I really appreciate this piece, Adam! I always respond in a similar way to friends who send me AI, and they always roll their eyes and puke. Anyway, I’d love to do some of my anachronistic hand-drawn-to-digital assets for your posters and such if you ever have a need. ❤️

Adam Cayton-Holland's avatar

thanks so much, Joanna! And thanks for reading. I'll holler at ya about a poster sometime soon!

Steve's avatar

Hey, this old man also appreciates the White Sox reference - subscription validated!